@wayfareangel

The logic here is flawed. The average DnD party is so incredibly chaotic, they would immediately draw the attention of chaos demons. They may actually be able to out chaos the chaos demons. It's that dance contest all over again...

@benjin3993

Orks watching a bard play his lute so hard another Ork explodes. Now they all charge into battle playing string instruments that cause nukes to go off

@eliotoole4534

Don’t forget about casting wish, perhaps the wizard wishes to heal the emperor

@deathsheep22

Hey look the warlock made a new pact!..... Why does the warlock smell so bad... What's... A nurgle.....

@Darkknight-rf2hw

They'll be buried in the sheer amount of bodies like that one pre dark times of technology planet did. But the players wpuld at least make sure a primarch or two remember their names and faces

@Lastofthesigilites

Have a level 20 cleric cure the God Emperor off the throne.

@zanepoke1074

Lvl 3 paladin using lay on hands to cure the emperor

@BlackdragonTheShadow

Hey if those few shorts were anything to go off on… sounds like a ton of fun

@williamadams930

Remember. The biggest trait among dnd characters is "Refuses to die quietly", and in a grimdark world, that earns you some of the best stories. "The Planet Broke Before The Guard" is still a story about the good guys losing, every heroic Kriegsman charge where five thousand "normal" men literally choke the enemies in a sea of blood for victory is still, really, a story about the good guys losing. But its about defiance. Armageddon rages, evil surrounds, and hell itself opens up in front of you, so laugh. Laugh your own madness and scream your own rage into the maw of oblivion and, knowing that you must die, stand, stand against the tides of Chaos and be the stone in its throat, that you shall carve out a tiny wound. That Chaos itself shall bleed for taking you.

@mariox204

The thing is a guardsman migth have commoner stats but the equipment is a totally diferent story with armor many times stronger than anything modern and the "flashligths" being guns that have looots of ammo that recharges with heat and pierces any modern armor

@zirtd9256

thumbs up for the chainsword

@mariobartolini2158

I mean, a level 5 fighter with a regular wooden bow can shoot down a brick wall, that's way better than what most space marines can do

Already at level 7, if the gm is using only basic commoner and guard stat blocks you can already siege a small city with a 5 man party

A level 1 barbarian on average hits harder than a natural lightning

If anything, a level 10 adventurer would probably beat a space marine most of the time

And at higher levels with all the crazy spells you get as a caster (expecially compared to wh psyons that risk exploding in demon juices if they try too hard) you could realistically change the fate of a battle with a party (not alone, with a proper army)

@reecedignan8365

The Wizard “I cast Magic Missile!”

The sniper 150m away “I cast hot-shot las round”

@alexfrankenfield1529

I would like to see an animated short, where the guardsman played D&D

@WetzforLife

Slaanesh meets a bard and has a career change to become a pious nun of the Ecclisiarchy.

@Idnekib

"Having a dog time losing" is the best description ever made about a DND game.

@johnathangoldstein9991

The bard is going to steal slannesh's spot as a chaos god

@kzazazazk

Bard becoming a follower of slanesh would put even the strongest noise marines to shame.

@TomFromMars

My thoughts exactly, it's really level dependant and i would have gone for about the same scale:
Level one is commoner
Level 5 is elite imperial guard
Level 10 is on par with orks and SM
Level 15 and up is world breaking.

But also you have to account for the ressources the factions can pour into a fight. I've never heard of a dnd bbeg using artillery. World destroying threats are used as a final plot point in dnd, they are a ressource easily managed and somewhat frequently used in wh40k, so in the end, the dnd party loses not in a fight but against real life war logistics.

@oldeskul

The wizard would get put on a black ship and sent to Holy Terra where they'd either get sacrificed to the Golden Throne or put through the Astra Telepathica. The sorcerer and the warlock would both get burned at the stake. The cleric would wind up in the Ecclesiarchy. The paladin would wind up becoming either a commissar or an Arbites. The rogue would wind up a member of an assassin temple.The fighter and the barbarian would get rolled up into the Imperial Guard. The monk would either get rolled up into the Ecclesiarchy, or the Arbites...maybe an enforcer. The druid, if they can avoid capture, would be chillin' on Catachan or some other heavily forested/jungle death world. That's assuming they're all human. If they're anything other than human, burnt at the stake and/or bolt round to the face and/or both,